For those interested in my short story but not enough to search for it, I'm including my link to this ribald, intelligent look at a possible 2030. It's on my Amazon author's page. Enjoy.
Do Well and Be Well.
http://www.amazon.com/author/johnfrazier
Monday, January 27, 2020
Saturday, January 25, 2020
An Interesting Development
Building upon the foundation of thought contained in these blogs, I have come to specific conclusions summed up in my new blogsite, Thinkerfeller.
Building upon the foundation of those blogs, I have written the first of a series of short stories, ribald and real, conserved under the series title, 'Making It'.
Since the Dark Net enjoys this blogsite, I thought I'd let all of you in on this new project. The story is titled 'The Buy: Making It' and is an examination of life in 2030, good and otherwise, with the changes I am advocating made.
It will be live on Amazon Kindle, device and app, on or about the 28th of January. Just search;
Erotica, Noir, Short Story, The Buy: Making It.
I obviously think you'll enjoy it. That's why I wrote it. Word of mouth will be appreciated.
Author: John Frazier
Do Well and Be Well.
Building upon the foundation of those blogs, I have written the first of a series of short stories, ribald and real, conserved under the series title, 'Making It'.
Since the Dark Net enjoys this blogsite, I thought I'd let all of you in on this new project. The story is titled 'The Buy: Making It' and is an examination of life in 2030, good and otherwise, with the changes I am advocating made.
It will be live on Amazon Kindle, device and app, on or about the 28th of January. Just search;
Erotica, Noir, Short Story, The Buy: Making It.
I obviously think you'll enjoy it. That's why I wrote it. Word of mouth will be appreciated.
Author: John Frazier
Do Well and Be Well.
Saturday, June 8, 2019
A Change Has Been Wrought
My blog, complete with new format, has moved to a different location, Thinkerfeller, on Blogger. Thanks for the reads and comments.
John Frazier aka Basil Brylcreem
John Frazier aka Basil Brylcreem
Monday, May 27, 2019
The Nature of Shifting Paradigms
Let me state clearly, everything in this blog is derivative of Thomas S Kuhn's landmark The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. The reader, possessed of reasonable intellectual talent, would easily do as well or better reading it. I suggest you do so.
First, I wish to emphasize the point that paradigm shifts happen in an instrumentalist fashion. One creates a model of significant explanatory power in terms of natural phenomena, however fluid and idiosyncratic their perception, as a general case. In competition with other models, this model proves the better. It is then, over generations as is the human Way, adopted.
One cannot author a paradigm shift. Any attempt to do so will shortcut the proper role of reason and probably do neurological damage to the brain. That is the classic mistake of the pedagogical megalomaniac who believes that the mind is theirs to shape.
Do Well and Be Well.
First, I wish to emphasize the point that paradigm shifts happen in an instrumentalist fashion. One creates a model of significant explanatory power in terms of natural phenomena, however fluid and idiosyncratic their perception, as a general case. In competition with other models, this model proves the better. It is then, over generations as is the human Way, adopted.
One cannot author a paradigm shift. Any attempt to do so will shortcut the proper role of reason and probably do neurological damage to the brain. That is the classic mistake of the pedagogical megalomaniac who believes that the mind is theirs to shape.
Do Well and Be Well.
Tuesday, May 14, 2019
Coinage versus Cash and Its Instruments
The intent of this blog is to examine the concept of money with an eye to reducing the current confusion about it by simplifying an analysis by making the taxonomy, historical and conceptual, more complex. And more conceptually difficult, be warned.
Coinage is the act of creating a standard value reference which is the essential act of arbitrage. Such a device allows a rough calculation that determines whether a good may be moved from point A to point B at a profit. Coinage makes trade possible and that's all it does.
Cash, on the other hand, and I am using the term as a taxon of the category, money, in order to separate and contrast the economies of coinage and cash, is an accounting device. It is a value reference of vastly more utility than hard money, coinage. It engenders sophisticated derivatives that make a general prosperity possible.
When the great Classical Liberal economist, Marshall speaks of Labor 'having' as the mark of a functioning economy, he is addressing the crux of the great and vicious arguments of the 20th century. He is of his age and speaking in terms of pounds sterling which were found woefully inadequate to the task of a general prosperity even as technology was taking the possibility of that concept to new heights. Thus we have institutionalized an accounting device and its liquid instruments as the standard for value reference, a value calculus employed in market operations.
Coinage depends on the supply of precious metal for monetary policy. Cash depends on complex calculations made possible by sophisticated accounting procedures and powerful economic paradigms for its management. It is obvious by inspection that the former is doomed to failure while the latter has a real chance of success.
Where do cryptocurrencies fall in this scheme? They fall significantly into the category, coinage. They are avowedly anti-bank and reject any notion of rational monetary policy. They are, like all coinage, doomed to failure. It is inherent in their conceptual base.
It is wise to remember that magpies are ridiculously attracted to shiny objects. Gold and silver are a priori valuable to the brain but they belong in beautiful adornments, not in coins of general use.
Do Well and Be Well
Coinage is the act of creating a standard value reference which is the essential act of arbitrage. Such a device allows a rough calculation that determines whether a good may be moved from point A to point B at a profit. Coinage makes trade possible and that's all it does.
Cash, on the other hand, and I am using the term as a taxon of the category, money, in order to separate and contrast the economies of coinage and cash, is an accounting device. It is a value reference of vastly more utility than hard money, coinage. It engenders sophisticated derivatives that make a general prosperity possible.
When the great Classical Liberal economist, Marshall speaks of Labor 'having' as the mark of a functioning economy, he is addressing the crux of the great and vicious arguments of the 20th century. He is of his age and speaking in terms of pounds sterling which were found woefully inadequate to the task of a general prosperity even as technology was taking the possibility of that concept to new heights. Thus we have institutionalized an accounting device and its liquid instruments as the standard for value reference, a value calculus employed in market operations.
Coinage depends on the supply of precious metal for monetary policy. Cash depends on complex calculations made possible by sophisticated accounting procedures and powerful economic paradigms for its management. It is obvious by inspection that the former is doomed to failure while the latter has a real chance of success.
Where do cryptocurrencies fall in this scheme? They fall significantly into the category, coinage. They are avowedly anti-bank and reject any notion of rational monetary policy. They are, like all coinage, doomed to failure. It is inherent in their conceptual base.
It is wise to remember that magpies are ridiculously attracted to shiny objects. Gold and silver are a priori valuable to the brain but they belong in beautiful adornments, not in coins of general use.
Do Well and Be Well
Saturday, May 4, 2019
Moving and Shaking
If the reader has ever been in a learning environment where a class was graded on a curve, it soon becomes obvious that a handful of people set the curve to which everyone else is graded. They are, in my usage, the movers and shakers of that group.
I have found that usage to be valuable when generalized to macro socioeconomic situations. Essentially, when one examines a consensus mover and shaker, one notices, in today's innovation orgy, they are setting a learning curve in concepts and technology necessary to adoption, acculturation. And just as in school, they appear to be really smart. They would. They're setting the curve to their abilities. That is the whole trick to moving and shaking; setting a curve, learning or grading, to yourself.
This society comes up well short of Mandarin standards so it is easily possible for some fairly limited individuals to set a learning curve to themselves and be welcome to do so as it would be well within the average comfort zone. Of course, that would put society behind the adoption curve when such a person is a mover and shaker and that is not necessarily a bad thing given the onslaught of innovation and the plasticity limits of the human brain.
Moving and shaking as setting a curve to yourself, a useful concept in social analysis.
Do Well and Be Well.
I have found that usage to be valuable when generalized to macro socioeconomic situations. Essentially, when one examines a consensus mover and shaker, one notices, in today's innovation orgy, they are setting a learning curve in concepts and technology necessary to adoption, acculturation. And just as in school, they appear to be really smart. They would. They're setting the curve to their abilities. That is the whole trick to moving and shaking; setting a curve, learning or grading, to yourself.
This society comes up well short of Mandarin standards so it is easily possible for some fairly limited individuals to set a learning curve to themselves and be welcome to do so as it would be well within the average comfort zone. Of course, that would put society behind the adoption curve when such a person is a mover and shaker and that is not necessarily a bad thing given the onslaught of innovation and the plasticity limits of the human brain.
Moving and shaking as setting a curve to yourself, a useful concept in social analysis.
Do Well and Be Well.
Thursday, April 11, 2019
Civilization; Some Thoughts
There are a number of attributes that go into making a human being human and even more that go into making that human a legal person, but the absolute sine qua non of humanity is that humans use technology to deal with reality. It is not just a role such as homo factorem, but an essential and defining attribute. Whether a hammer or a microscope, humans have a technological interface with all reality.
Civilization is no more than technological culture but it goes someplace. It moves humankind to the Light of health, sanity, and peace. What describes the wars of the last century better than a failure of culture to contain new and powerful technology? A failure of civilization? A consensus certainty. So, we build a better technological culture that can contain all our new machine friends and humans do consider technology friendly somewhere in their cells. We rebuild our civilization and continue to move to the Light which is always over our heads so we can read a book.
That is truly Man's Fate, to be a technologist, to be civilized, to move out of Darkness and into Light. It is our Way.
Do Well and Be Well.
Civilization is no more than technological culture but it goes someplace. It moves humankind to the Light of health, sanity, and peace. What describes the wars of the last century better than a failure of culture to contain new and powerful technology? A failure of civilization? A consensus certainty. So, we build a better technological culture that can contain all our new machine friends and humans do consider technology friendly somewhere in their cells. We rebuild our civilization and continue to move to the Light which is always over our heads so we can read a book.
That is truly Man's Fate, to be a technologist, to be civilized, to move out of Darkness and into Light. It is our Way.
Do Well and Be Well.
Thursday, March 21, 2019
The Middle Ages; A Revision
Alternatively to the Middle Ages, we know this period as the Dark Ages and even more to the point of the modern ethos, the Age of Faith. A great age of Faith it was, as advertised, but not dark like the Twentieth century. Peasants and their associations, the village council and guilds, replaced slaves. The Byzantine ethos, Greek and Roman culture conserved under Christian administration, became the common culture. Feudalism was itself arguably Byzantine and like Byzantium, not quite civilized.
There were books, a Byzantine invention, and libraries, private and monastic but above all there was trade. Bismarck's famous observation that war was diplomacy by other means easily extends to trade being war by other means and business was discouraged as injurious to Christian values as there is little room for those values in war.
The grand triumph of economics as the centerpiece of the modern ethos comes obviously at the expense of an extraordinary Byzantine exercise in civilizing barbarians. As the United States, singularly well suited to it, has repeatedly had the role of modernist Byzantium thrust upon it, it is interesting that that description, while encompassing a thousand years of the history of civilization, won't quite fly. It describes the role but omits the philosophical differences.
Just some thoughts marking a personal intellectual journey. I am become revisionist.
Do Well and Be Well.
There were books, a Byzantine invention, and libraries, private and monastic but above all there was trade. Bismarck's famous observation that war was diplomacy by other means easily extends to trade being war by other means and business was discouraged as injurious to Christian values as there is little room for those values in war.
The grand triumph of economics as the centerpiece of the modern ethos comes obviously at the expense of an extraordinary Byzantine exercise in civilizing barbarians. As the United States, singularly well suited to it, has repeatedly had the role of modernist Byzantium thrust upon it, it is interesting that that description, while encompassing a thousand years of the history of civilization, won't quite fly. It describes the role but omits the philosophical differences.
Just some thoughts marking a personal intellectual journey. I am become revisionist.
Do Well and Be Well.
Saturday, February 23, 2019
Information, Ideation, Productivity, and Civilization
Civilization is no more than the attempt to remove humankind from the dismal swamp of Nature and its pathological vagaries in order to induce a common condition of sane cognition. Access to information drives civilization. Ideation drives and is driven by information. Productivity increases are driven by ideation and productivity drives material existence, the limit of the possible of civilization. They are all linked.
The quest of the intellectual exercise which is the central element of civilization is perfect information. Game performance and market performance, a related phenomenon, both improve with better information. Assuming perfect information makes Game Theory analysis possible and that describes the motivation for the evolution of civilization, iterative attempts to achieve perfect information in order to improve performance.
This has resulted in digitization of information. Today, we have digital platforms, Google, Amazon, providing access to digital libraries of databases and paradigms in the attempt to create an easily accessed Library of Civilization, all extant written works. In addition to this Database, there are online attempts to make paradigms accessible, MOOC's, a sort of University of Civilization. The net result of this is to realize the limits of the plasticity of the human brain and that is a driving factor in developing artificial intelligence analysis.
Central to the central element of civilization, the intellectual exercise, is ideation, the creation of ideas. There are three aspects to ideation: intellect, the talent of integrating new information into a coherent body of knowledge; intellectual curiosity, an appetite for information, a hunger for the next fact, the next insight; and access to information, as covered above. These aspects describe the process by which ideas are generated, the ideas which define our possibilities.
Productivity, which is the measure of the efficiency of Labor, describes the process, in Western Civilization, under the tenets of Classical Liberal economics, by which ideas are reified into product and process to the end of the greatest good for the greatest number by which we mean Utility.
By simple logic, the greater the productivity of Labor, the greater the Utility of that economy, to which end we have engaged in a vast program of Research and Development and entrepreneurship. We are are now in a position to judge the consequences of such an exercise. They are:
1. The marginalization of Labor as a production input.
2. As Labor becomes more and more inconsequential to the cost of production, markets, which primarily set the price of Labor in Classical Liberal economics, move into focus as bazaars of arbitrage, a significantly different role.
3. Money, which value is tied to the cost of Labor in Classical Liberal economics, becomes of indeterminate value in such conditions and must seek definition elsewhere.
As this exercise in productivity proceeds we are approaching the point of self-reproducing automata, the mathematical model of which was developed by John von Neumann, which undercuts the assumptions of Classical Liberal economics by making the productivity of Labor approach infinity.
I do not know what economic analysis will replace Classical Liberal economics but I suspect it will include AI as an essential element.
Do Well and Be Well.
The quest of the intellectual exercise which is the central element of civilization is perfect information. Game performance and market performance, a related phenomenon, both improve with better information. Assuming perfect information makes Game Theory analysis possible and that describes the motivation for the evolution of civilization, iterative attempts to achieve perfect information in order to improve performance.
This has resulted in digitization of information. Today, we have digital platforms, Google, Amazon, providing access to digital libraries of databases and paradigms in the attempt to create an easily accessed Library of Civilization, all extant written works. In addition to this Database, there are online attempts to make paradigms accessible, MOOC's, a sort of University of Civilization. The net result of this is to realize the limits of the plasticity of the human brain and that is a driving factor in developing artificial intelligence analysis.
Central to the central element of civilization, the intellectual exercise, is ideation, the creation of ideas. There are three aspects to ideation: intellect, the talent of integrating new information into a coherent body of knowledge; intellectual curiosity, an appetite for information, a hunger for the next fact, the next insight; and access to information, as covered above. These aspects describe the process by which ideas are generated, the ideas which define our possibilities.
Productivity, which is the measure of the efficiency of Labor, describes the process, in Western Civilization, under the tenets of Classical Liberal economics, by which ideas are reified into product and process to the end of the greatest good for the greatest number by which we mean Utility.
By simple logic, the greater the productivity of Labor, the greater the Utility of that economy, to which end we have engaged in a vast program of Research and Development and entrepreneurship. We are are now in a position to judge the consequences of such an exercise. They are:
1. The marginalization of Labor as a production input.
2. As Labor becomes more and more inconsequential to the cost of production, markets, which primarily set the price of Labor in Classical Liberal economics, move into focus as bazaars of arbitrage, a significantly different role.
3. Money, which value is tied to the cost of Labor in Classical Liberal economics, becomes of indeterminate value in such conditions and must seek definition elsewhere.
As this exercise in productivity proceeds we are approaching the point of self-reproducing automata, the mathematical model of which was developed by John von Neumann, which undercuts the assumptions of Classical Liberal economics by making the productivity of Labor approach infinity.
I do not know what economic analysis will replace Classical Liberal economics but I suspect it will include AI as an essential element.
Do Well and Be Well.
Saturday, January 19, 2019
Brain Pain: Definition, Mechanisms, and Address
What is this phenomenon that I am calling 'brain pain'? It is the patterns of aberrant behavior which indicate some sort of neurological deficit. That is to say, dislocations, decay, and destruction of neural structures from various causes including but not limited to, acquisition and integration of new information, pathological conditions, substance abuse, and environmental factors as they are exhibited in generally considered aberrant behavior but not felt as actual pain.
Substance abuse and nerve toxins are generally conceded to destroy neural tissue, actual trauma which is largely painless, brain pain. Acquisition and integration of new information causes the dislocation of synapses and dendrites, unfelt trauma, brain pain. It is important to note that the dislocation of neural structure due to acquiring and integrating new information, information overload, is as traumatic as a brain injury in its behavioral effects.
Any superficial neural trauma, not destroying the actual neuron, can be dealt with by creating new neural structure by thinking and hypothesizing. The process of integrating new information should be carried through to a logical end, to the degree possible, to diminish brain pain. Similarly, any microtrauma due to nerve antagonists can be dealt with by reading, thinking, and hypothesizing.
The point of the exercise is to characterize specific behavior patterns as the result of brain pain in order to personally better understand ourselves.
Do Well and Be Well.
Substance abuse and nerve toxins are generally conceded to destroy neural tissue, actual trauma which is largely painless, brain pain. Acquisition and integration of new information causes the dislocation of synapses and dendrites, unfelt trauma, brain pain. It is important to note that the dislocation of neural structure due to acquiring and integrating new information, information overload, is as traumatic as a brain injury in its behavioral effects.
Any superficial neural trauma, not destroying the actual neuron, can be dealt with by creating new neural structure by thinking and hypothesizing. The process of integrating new information should be carried through to a logical end, to the degree possible, to diminish brain pain. Similarly, any microtrauma due to nerve antagonists can be dealt with by reading, thinking, and hypothesizing.
The point of the exercise is to characterize specific behavior patterns as the result of brain pain in order to personally better understand ourselves.
Do Well and Be Well.
Saturday, November 3, 2018
Personality and the Coherent Volition Regimen: A Summary
This blog ends my eight year experiment in writing a blog and promoting it on social media. Although I have at times managed a significant readership, the social media companies don't particularly like what I'm doing. Apparently it doesn't translate into the kind of data that can be monetized.
A niche does exist today for a serious site dedicated to discovery with an interactive interface. It would, however, run counter to the massive data harvesting that characterizes social media. It would not be well understood.
Now to the summary of the previous four blogs. First, humans, animals, and smart machines all possess a coherent volition regimen (CVR), a consistent idiosyncratic manner of perception, cognition, volition, and action with feedback describing reliable patterns of cultivated behavior. This cultivated behavior, together with a priori elements, we call personality, that which makes a human a person. Dogs and robots do not, by definition, have a personality. They cannot be a person. They do have a CVR.
Essential to human social existence is the concept, the role, of moral agent, the ability to estimate and codify a successful value system and behave to it. This is beyond the capabilities of dogs and, at this point, artificial intelligence. Humans as persons are moral agents. They are alone in creation in that.
Structurally, the whole of human social existence revolves around humans as legal persons. While groups of persons, a corporation, may be treated as a legal person, no animal, no algorithm can be so considered. No robot, however capable, can be anything but a mechanical working animal, kept or owned and very likely licensed.
What dogs, humans, and smart machines are, as a common classification, are players. They game as a metaphor for social existence. They can all play games to a set of rules. They are players.
While the thought developed and expressed in these five blogs and the previous two on volition is not particularly rigorous, it has been a difficult logical puzzle to solve in a reasonable fashion. I think that I have done that and derived a common reference that differentiates among humans, animals, and robots adequately. It may prove to be valuable.
Do Well and Be Well
A niche does exist today for a serious site dedicated to discovery with an interactive interface. It would, however, run counter to the massive data harvesting that characterizes social media. It would not be well understood.
Now to the summary of the previous four blogs. First, humans, animals, and smart machines all possess a coherent volition regimen (CVR), a consistent idiosyncratic manner of perception, cognition, volition, and action with feedback describing reliable patterns of cultivated behavior. This cultivated behavior, together with a priori elements, we call personality, that which makes a human a person. Dogs and robots do not, by definition, have a personality. They cannot be a person. They do have a CVR.
Essential to human social existence is the concept, the role, of moral agent, the ability to estimate and codify a successful value system and behave to it. This is beyond the capabilities of dogs and, at this point, artificial intelligence. Humans as persons are moral agents. They are alone in creation in that.
Structurally, the whole of human social existence revolves around humans as legal persons. While groups of persons, a corporation, may be treated as a legal person, no animal, no algorithm can be so considered. No robot, however capable, can be anything but a mechanical working animal, kept or owned and very likely licensed.
What dogs, humans, and smart machines are, as a common classification, are players. They game as a metaphor for social existence. They can all play games to a set of rules. They are players.
While the thought developed and expressed in these five blogs and the previous two on volition is not particularly rigorous, it has been a difficult logical puzzle to solve in a reasonable fashion. I think that I have done that and derived a common reference that differentiates among humans, animals, and robots adequately. It may prove to be valuable.
Do Well and Be Well
Friday, October 26, 2018
Personality, Player, and the Coherent Volition Regimen
'Game' occurs significantly in human descriptions and even analysis of human affairs. As described earlier in this blog series, 'game' appears to be a Kantian a priori, an unknowable thing in itself. It is here, in gameplay, that anthropomorphic errors happen frequently with respect to animals and even machines. Clever beasts can play simple games to a set of rules. Smart machines can play complex games to a set of rules. Mistakes are easy.
The focus of these mistakes is the nature of 'player', a participant in a game who, or which, is proficient in gameplay, an adept. Given the a priori nature of 'game' and the significant use of the game metaphor in human society, it is very easy to mistake player for person. Persons are human beings. Players have a capable coherent volition regimen but are not necessarily persons.
Dogs are players. Observe a clever dog playing frisbee. They are proficient at simple game play. I once kept a clever Labrador which I taught to play a rudimentary game of football (Labradors' jaws are so hinged that they can grip a football) The dog became a proficient player, an adept at the game, and even attempted to teach the game to other dogs. That is a player. That is not a person.
Smart machines are players. Observe the amazing success they have achieved in board games against expert human opponents. They are players. They are not persons.
However much animals and machines are players, however skilled their coherent volition regimen, they are not persons. They cannot estimate and codify the rules of the rules of 'game'. Therefore they cannot possibly be moral or legal persons or any person at all. They are limited to the society of dogs, a dog pack, or the society of smart machines, a scaled-out network. Human society is reserved for persons who may, in fact, keep machines and animals, both of which having roughly the same moral and legal status.
Next blog: Personality and the Coherent Volition Regimen; A Summary
Do Well and Be Well
The focus of these mistakes is the nature of 'player', a participant in a game who, or which, is proficient in gameplay, an adept. Given the a priori nature of 'game' and the significant use of the game metaphor in human society, it is very easy to mistake player for person. Persons are human beings. Players have a capable coherent volition regimen but are not necessarily persons.
Dogs are players. Observe a clever dog playing frisbee. They are proficient at simple game play. I once kept a clever Labrador which I taught to play a rudimentary game of football (Labradors' jaws are so hinged that they can grip a football) The dog became a proficient player, an adept at the game, and even attempted to teach the game to other dogs. That is a player. That is not a person.
Smart machines are players. Observe the amazing success they have achieved in board games against expert human opponents. They are players. They are not persons.
However much animals and machines are players, however skilled their coherent volition regimen, they are not persons. They cannot estimate and codify the rules of the rules of 'game'. Therefore they cannot possibly be moral or legal persons or any person at all. They are limited to the society of dogs, a dog pack, or the society of smart machines, a scaled-out network. Human society is reserved for persons who may, in fact, keep machines and animals, both of which having roughly the same moral and legal status.
Next blog: Personality and the Coherent Volition Regimen; A Summary
Do Well and Be Well
Friday, October 19, 2018
Personality, Legal Person, and the Coherent Volition Regimen
Legal Person:
An individual or group that is allowed by law to take legal action, as plaintiff or defendant. It may include natural persons as well as fictitious persons (such as corporations)
So, the derivation is personality defining person and person being eligible to be a legal person, subject to a body of law, expected to behave to those laws, and participatory in the process of the law. The body of law itself is rooted theoretically in a social contract, a negotiated quid pro quo of what I can do and can't do and what you can and can't do. The social contract, a baseline reference for rational social behavior, is only a useful fiction. The law is a living thing having many contributing factors including the possible.
Artificial intelligence, having a functional coherent volition regimen (CVR), and the machines it drives have no personality and therefore cannot be any person and definitely not a legal person. Like a dog, which also has a CVR but not a personality, it is subject to the regulation of law, especially in terms of liability, but not participatory in that process. It must be in the 'keeping' of a legal person, or owned as commonly construed, in order to rationalize liability and dangerous behavior and bring smart machines into social and legal accountability, very much as the law treats working animals.
It becomes essential on the force of this argument that we, as persons, agree on the logic that machines, as much as is economically possible, adapt to humans and not vice versa in order to empower humane social existence. We need to negotiate, as a social contract, the role of owner as that of empowered keeper, a steward of a specified domain, usually an object or enterprise, but including smart machines and real property.
On that basis, smart machines must then, logically and legally, be in the keeping of a legal person, licensed to such a bonded person, in order to effect the redress of liabilities for wrongful action. They may be subject to licensing fees for redress of the social cost of their employment, which is to say, just as a runaway horse's keeper is liable for consequent damage, so a robot's keeper is liable for consequent socioeconomic damage. A smart machine is not a simple drill press. It is closer to a mechanical draft horse.
Next blog: Personality, Player, and the Coherent Volition Regimen
Do Well and Be Well
An individual or group that is allowed by law to take legal action, as plaintiff or defendant. It may include natural persons as well as fictitious persons (such as corporations)
So, the derivation is personality defining person and person being eligible to be a legal person, subject to a body of law, expected to behave to those laws, and participatory in the process of the law. The body of law itself is rooted theoretically in a social contract, a negotiated quid pro quo of what I can do and can't do and what you can and can't do. The social contract, a baseline reference for rational social behavior, is only a useful fiction. The law is a living thing having many contributing factors including the possible.
Artificial intelligence, having a functional coherent volition regimen (CVR), and the machines it drives have no personality and therefore cannot be any person and definitely not a legal person. Like a dog, which also has a CVR but not a personality, it is subject to the regulation of law, especially in terms of liability, but not participatory in that process. It must be in the 'keeping' of a legal person, or owned as commonly construed, in order to rationalize liability and dangerous behavior and bring smart machines into social and legal accountability, very much as the law treats working animals.
It becomes essential on the force of this argument that we, as persons, agree on the logic that machines, as much as is economically possible, adapt to humans and not vice versa in order to empower humane social existence. We need to negotiate, as a social contract, the role of owner as that of empowered keeper, a steward of a specified domain, usually an object or enterprise, but including smart machines and real property.
On that basis, smart machines must then, logically and legally, be in the keeping of a legal person, licensed to such a bonded person, in order to effect the redress of liabilities for wrongful action. They may be subject to licensing fees for redress of the social cost of their employment, which is to say, just as a runaway horse's keeper is liable for consequent damage, so a robot's keeper is liable for consequent socioeconomic damage. A smart machine is not a simple drill press. It is closer to a mechanical draft horse.
Next blog: Personality, Player, and the Coherent Volition Regimen
Do Well and Be Well
Friday, October 12, 2018
Personality, Moral Agency, and the Coherent Volition Regimen
I am here involved in the search for differences and equivalents in human, animal, and machine psychology, to use the word loosely, in an effort to adequately place smart machines in a large context socioeconomic system. Being oriented in one's context is an essential starting point for the building of a sane mind and we cannot be sane in our employment of such machines until we can adequately place them in our context.
The topic of the first blog was personality as a special case of coherent volition regimen (CVR). Today's subject is moral agency as essentially human. What is moral agency? It is the deployment of personality into the world as directed by a codified value system, rational and irrational. A value system is the rules of the rules of a game of existence, material and social existence. However, not even humans can abstract the rules of the rules of a game from experience. According to Ludwig Wittgenstein, the logician, we can only estimate them. It appears that 'game', the rules of the rules, is a Kantian a priori.
Animals notoriously play games. They can figure out the rules of some games. They apparently have 'game' a priori also. However, they cannot estimate the rules of the rules of a game, much less approximately codify them into a somewhat rational value system. That is what makes moral agency an essentially human role.
Artificial intelligence can also figure out the rules of a game. It can, to certain and increasing extent, explain itself. We will have to wait and see whether it can codify the rules of the rules without an a priori construct. I am betting that it can't. I am betting on human exceptionalism. However, with estimates of 1000 IQ for neural networks currently in development, the odds are close to even.
Moral agency, like language, like the opposable thumb, like the large complex brain, like the penchant for technology, is an important component of the argument for human exceptionalism. Dogs have a CVR but they cannot codify a value system. An AI robot has a CVR but it probably cannot codify a value system. We are very likely alone in that.
Next blog: Personality, Legal Persons, and the Coherent Volition Regimen
Do Well and Be Well
The topic of the first blog was personality as a special case of coherent volition regimen (CVR). Today's subject is moral agency as essentially human. What is moral agency? It is the deployment of personality into the world as directed by a codified value system, rational and irrational. A value system is the rules of the rules of a game of existence, material and social existence. However, not even humans can abstract the rules of the rules of a game from experience. According to Ludwig Wittgenstein, the logician, we can only estimate them. It appears that 'game', the rules of the rules, is a Kantian a priori.
Animals notoriously play games. They can figure out the rules of some games. They apparently have 'game' a priori also. However, they cannot estimate the rules of the rules of a game, much less approximately codify them into a somewhat rational value system. That is what makes moral agency an essentially human role.
Artificial intelligence can also figure out the rules of a game. It can, to certain and increasing extent, explain itself. We will have to wait and see whether it can codify the rules of the rules without an a priori construct. I am betting that it can't. I am betting on human exceptionalism. However, with estimates of 1000 IQ for neural networks currently in development, the odds are close to even.
Moral agency, like language, like the opposable thumb, like the large complex brain, like the penchant for technology, is an important component of the argument for human exceptionalism. Dogs have a CVR but they cannot codify a value system. An AI robot has a CVR but it probably cannot codify a value system. We are very likely alone in that.
Next blog: Personality, Legal Persons, and the Coherent Volition Regimen
Do Well and Be Well
Sunday, October 7, 2018
A General Concept of Personality; the Coherent Volition Regimen
First, and make no mistake about my intent, personality is an essentially human phenomenon. Using the word properly, dogs do not have a personality. Chimps do not have a personality and, above all, machines do not have a personality. However, the consistent anthropomorphic mistakes made in reference to other creatures and even machines indicate that something like a personality is present. In this blog I am searching for that something.
What is a personality? Personality is what makes a human being a person, a special being capable of moral and legal behavior, capable of somewhat rational social existence. A personality is the specific attributes of a specific human being. In the Aristotelian construct we know as 'qua', a thing in the role of other, it is the defining characteristics of the human thing who assumes social roles in the larger construct of social existence. In a simple example, Rex, in the role of lawyer, makes his case to the jury. In the Aristotelian sense, water qua ice, Rex qua lawyer is essentially the same bundle of attributes differently configured. He has the same personality. The problem, then, is to rephrase an essentially human phenomenon so as to account for anthropomorphic errors. Let me try.
A personality is a type of 'coherent volition regimen' (CVR) composed of idiosyncratic manners of perception, cognition, volition, and action in concert with a feedback loop so that a consistent pattern of relatively unique cultivated behavior, reasonably adaptive over time, is reliably exhibited. That does describe a personality and a coherent volition regimen.
So, dogs do have a CVR but not a personality, although much more of it is wired into their brains than humans have a priori. A robot driven by machine learning also has a CVR but not a personality. They are not persons in the grand scheme of social existence which I examine in the next three blogs.
Next: Personality, Moral Agency, and Coherent Volition Regimens
Do Well and Be Well
What is a personality? Personality is what makes a human being a person, a special being capable of moral and legal behavior, capable of somewhat rational social existence. A personality is the specific attributes of a specific human being. In the Aristotelian construct we know as 'qua', a thing in the role of other, it is the defining characteristics of the human thing who assumes social roles in the larger construct of social existence. In a simple example, Rex, in the role of lawyer, makes his case to the jury. In the Aristotelian sense, water qua ice, Rex qua lawyer is essentially the same bundle of attributes differently configured. He has the same personality. The problem, then, is to rephrase an essentially human phenomenon so as to account for anthropomorphic errors. Let me try.
A personality is a type of 'coherent volition regimen' (CVR) composed of idiosyncratic manners of perception, cognition, volition, and action in concert with a feedback loop so that a consistent pattern of relatively unique cultivated behavior, reasonably adaptive over time, is reliably exhibited. That does describe a personality and a coherent volition regimen.
So, dogs do have a CVR but not a personality, although much more of it is wired into their brains than humans have a priori. A robot driven by machine learning also has a CVR but not a personality. They are not persons in the grand scheme of social existence which I examine in the next three blogs.
Next: Personality, Moral Agency, and Coherent Volition Regimens
Do Well and Be Well
Saturday, September 29, 2018
Notes on Volition and Property
I am a behaviorist when it comes to volition. The act and the will are undifferentiated. I do not know what you intend except by what you do.
When we lack a significant commonality with another human being and, in consequence, treat them in a cavalier fashion we are said to be alienated in the vulgar if not the clinical sense of the word. I would offer a closer descriptive term. I would say that without the relational threads that compose social existence, we 'objectify' other human beings. Which is to say, we treat them as though they lack significant volition, as a stone, as a tree, as an object. And we do so as a more capable being, as a human to a dog. The dynamic resembles a behavioral hypothesis to be proved or disproved.
While I am willing to leave the why of humans doing this to psychology, I am concerned about the philosophical consequences. 'Object', as it comes into the English language from the Greek, means to present to the mind. Apparently, by so doing, it also means to include in one's social sphere with all the categories of social hierarchy. We seem to have a prejudice wired into our brains, perhaps related to fight or flight, that anything not immediately identifiable with ourselves in reliable relationships, my dog, my neighbor, your wall, is an object lacking volition until it proves otherwise, a sort of analytical xenophobia.
Thus the human need to 'know' their universe resolves as a need to establish reliable relationships with everything in that universe and that ordering inclination resolves in terms of greater and lesser volition, both cognitive horsepower and physical capability. Property then resolves as a reliable relationship, not 'possession ' as the concept has evolved, but 'keeping' as the Ancient Greeks had it.
If one removes possession from the lexicon of property, robots present an interesting problem. Soon to have the cognitive horsepower of a smart dog and the capability of significant physical action, they resolve in a complex 'keeping' relationship such as one has with a dog. In such a relationship they are eligible for licensing as a means of establishing legal liabilities and responsibilities. And if subject to licensing, they are subject to licensing fees, a new rational and valuable revenue stream.
Do Well and Be Well
When we lack a significant commonality with another human being and, in consequence, treat them in a cavalier fashion we are said to be alienated in the vulgar if not the clinical sense of the word. I would offer a closer descriptive term. I would say that without the relational threads that compose social existence, we 'objectify' other human beings. Which is to say, we treat them as though they lack significant volition, as a stone, as a tree, as an object. And we do so as a more capable being, as a human to a dog. The dynamic resembles a behavioral hypothesis to be proved or disproved.
While I am willing to leave the why of humans doing this to psychology, I am concerned about the philosophical consequences. 'Object', as it comes into the English language from the Greek, means to present to the mind. Apparently, by so doing, it also means to include in one's social sphere with all the categories of social hierarchy. We seem to have a prejudice wired into our brains, perhaps related to fight or flight, that anything not immediately identifiable with ourselves in reliable relationships, my dog, my neighbor, your wall, is an object lacking volition until it proves otherwise, a sort of analytical xenophobia.
Thus the human need to 'know' their universe resolves as a need to establish reliable relationships with everything in that universe and that ordering inclination resolves in terms of greater and lesser volition, both cognitive horsepower and physical capability. Property then resolves as a reliable relationship, not 'possession ' as the concept has evolved, but 'keeping' as the Ancient Greeks had it.
If one removes possession from the lexicon of property, robots present an interesting problem. Soon to have the cognitive horsepower of a smart dog and the capability of significant physical action, they resolve in a complex 'keeping' relationship such as one has with a dog. In such a relationship they are eligible for licensing as a means of establishing legal liabilities and responsibilities. And if subject to licensing, they are subject to licensing fees, a new rational and valuable revenue stream.
Do Well and Be Well
Sunday, September 2, 2018
Property, Economic Goods, and Capital Goods: A Reflection
The taxonomy is classic, property, economic good, Capital Good. The importance of that categorical derivation is essential to economics. So, noticing a certain vague confusion concerning the nature of property, I decided, presumptuous I know, to reason into the subject a decent definition of it.
In what manner do we own anything in the philosophical sense, excluding custom or psychology and convention or law? To own something in the philosophical sense is, first, to possess more volition than it does and, second, to direct it in a reasonable fashion. I mean by volition, rational will composed of logical reflection and a consequent action. This is not the current sense of the word which is more tuned to the pragmatic, small 't', truth and consequent action, but it is the sense of the concept of property as it has come into being.
Philosophically, then, volition or the lack of it defines the category of property or what may be considered property. Law and psychology have placed serious constraints on that definition to the end of humane social existence. A stone has no volition. It must be directed if it is to 'do' anything. If I am directing the stone, say placing it into a wall, it is in my 'keeping' in the Ancient Greek sense of ownership by legitimate use. Past that 'keeping' as a philosophically sound position, property is all custom and convention. It is a dynamic concept changing from society to society and time to time.
Given this flux of meaning, how do we ascertain property in the economic sense? It is, in short, a matter of picking nits through specific custom and convention to variable conclusions. This is intolerable philosophically. So, let me continue to be cheeky and rethink the very idea of economic good.
First, significantly diverging from Marshall, the proper subject of economics is material existence, the art of being in time and space and all the objects and services that that entails but not the ideas and beliefs motivating the keeping of objects and the contracting of services, which I term custom or psychology. Psychology is psychology. Law is law. Economics is economics. Whatever valuable constructs psychology brings to the table of economic discussion, it is not germane to the subject of property, beings with volition 'keeping' 'objects' with less volition. Law is only a constraint upon the possible in economic analysis.
The concept of property as stated above is cut and dried and clear. Even as custom and convention muddy those waters so does technology. If I deploy a robot possessed of machine learning, reason, and significant mechanical movement, action, do I, in fact, own that robot or an I contracting with it for labor services? The AI currently in development creates a serious exception to robots as Capital Goods in the philosophical sense.
The question on the table of economics is not easy to answer. It is to define the point at which robots move from object to contractor, from Capital Good to Labor Good. Society waits for the answer.
Do Well and Be Well.
In what manner do we own anything in the philosophical sense, excluding custom or psychology and convention or law? To own something in the philosophical sense is, first, to possess more volition than it does and, second, to direct it in a reasonable fashion. I mean by volition, rational will composed of logical reflection and a consequent action. This is not the current sense of the word which is more tuned to the pragmatic, small 't', truth and consequent action, but it is the sense of the concept of property as it has come into being.
Philosophically, then, volition or the lack of it defines the category of property or what may be considered property. Law and psychology have placed serious constraints on that definition to the end of humane social existence. A stone has no volition. It must be directed if it is to 'do' anything. If I am directing the stone, say placing it into a wall, it is in my 'keeping' in the Ancient Greek sense of ownership by legitimate use. Past that 'keeping' as a philosophically sound position, property is all custom and convention. It is a dynamic concept changing from society to society and time to time.
Given this flux of meaning, how do we ascertain property in the economic sense? It is, in short, a matter of picking nits through specific custom and convention to variable conclusions. This is intolerable philosophically. So, let me continue to be cheeky and rethink the very idea of economic good.
First, significantly diverging from Marshall, the proper subject of economics is material existence, the art of being in time and space and all the objects and services that that entails but not the ideas and beliefs motivating the keeping of objects and the contracting of services, which I term custom or psychology. Psychology is psychology. Law is law. Economics is economics. Whatever valuable constructs psychology brings to the table of economic discussion, it is not germane to the subject of property, beings with volition 'keeping' 'objects' with less volition. Law is only a constraint upon the possible in economic analysis.
The concept of property as stated above is cut and dried and clear. Even as custom and convention muddy those waters so does technology. If I deploy a robot possessed of machine learning, reason, and significant mechanical movement, action, do I, in fact, own that robot or an I contracting with it for labor services? The AI currently in development creates a serious exception to robots as Capital Goods in the philosophical sense.
The question on the table of economics is not easy to answer. It is to define the point at which robots move from object to contractor, from Capital Good to Labor Good. Society waits for the answer.
Do Well and Be Well.
Sunday, May 20, 2018
The Necessity of Basic Income and Free Education
Our concept of the social responsibility for the economic well-being of individuals in our political economy is being disrupted. With the advent of globalism the very idea of separate political economies is under pressure. It is becoming clear that we must be both more generous in our societal amendments to income and education and more strict in our fiscal accountability, a neat trick I must admit.
The health of a political economy, production, distribution, and administration, is now and will be forever measured by the comparative value of its currency in relation to world currencies in a free market. There is no absolute measure of a healthy econom, only relative health. Basically, it works or it doesn't. This series of blogs is an attempt to systematically address the black box of the allocation of wealth for socioeconomic good in the hope of rationalizing that process to achieve economic and social accountability in the political economy.
By creating an equation that measures the effect of social spending on the 'goodness' of its currency, I have created a theoretical metric measuring the abstract health of a political economy in terms of its currency without comparative valuation. It is an index useful in judging the wisdom of expenditures beyond current economics so that the politically possible will be realized efficiently and responsibly.
What of the politically possible? It is becoming conventional wisdom that our consumerist capitalist political economy cannot maintain both growth and capital concentration without priming the pump of consumer spending. The idea of a basic income is not just to replace social welfare programs but to cut to the chase of putting more money in the hands of consumers to maintain growth and the concentration of capital. As I argued earlier, a licensing fee for automation would accomplish that in a fair bargain.
While the bar to education is coming down, online schools and access to texts and explanatory materials for the autodidact, the bar in the workplace for necessary paradigms and skill sets is going up. This happy coincidence also requires monetary support in order to work. We must provide it. There has never been a period of creative destruction quite like the one we face.
And that brings me to the subject of venture capital. It is not in the nature of venture capital, a mass industrial institution, to provide funds on a substantial risk/ moderate reward basis and the only mechanism we have in place to manage this intense creative destruction is venture capital. We need to create a public venture capital corporation to fund the small bespoke factories of the future and their economic infrastructure on a breakeven basis. Faced with the social default of meaningless existence, we must assert our better nature, our life force, and move ahead into a world of possibility and meaning.
Thank You Kind Readers,
Do Well and Be Well
The health of a political economy, production, distribution, and administration, is now and will be forever measured by the comparative value of its currency in relation to world currencies in a free market. There is no absolute measure of a healthy econom, only relative health. Basically, it works or it doesn't. This series of blogs is an attempt to systematically address the black box of the allocation of wealth for socioeconomic good in the hope of rationalizing that process to achieve economic and social accountability in the political economy.
By creating an equation that measures the effect of social spending on the 'goodness' of its currency, I have created a theoretical metric measuring the abstract health of a political economy in terms of its currency without comparative valuation. It is an index useful in judging the wisdom of expenditures beyond current economics so that the politically possible will be realized efficiently and responsibly.
What of the politically possible? It is becoming conventional wisdom that our consumerist capitalist political economy cannot maintain both growth and capital concentration without priming the pump of consumer spending. The idea of a basic income is not just to replace social welfare programs but to cut to the chase of putting more money in the hands of consumers to maintain growth and the concentration of capital. As I argued earlier, a licensing fee for automation would accomplish that in a fair bargain.
While the bar to education is coming down, online schools and access to texts and explanatory materials for the autodidact, the bar in the workplace for necessary paradigms and skill sets is going up. This happy coincidence also requires monetary support in order to work. We must provide it. There has never been a period of creative destruction quite like the one we face.
And that brings me to the subject of venture capital. It is not in the nature of venture capital, a mass industrial institution, to provide funds on a substantial risk/ moderate reward basis and the only mechanism we have in place to manage this intense creative destruction is venture capital. We need to create a public venture capital corporation to fund the small bespoke factories of the future and their economic infrastructure on a breakeven basis. Faced with the social default of meaningless existence, we must assert our better nature, our life force, and move ahead into a world of possibility and meaning.
Thank You Kind Readers,
Do Well and Be Well
Saturday, May 19, 2018
Bespoke Production: The Humane Resolution of Mass Industrialism
Blog 3
What I am calling Value Dilution Economics is based upon the observation that when one leverages their economy, whether with Keynesian mechanics or supply side mechanics, one either overcooks their economy or overcooks their society and dilutes either the value of money or the quality of their social existence. It is a very reliable and historically evident relationship. We are now moving into the Age of Productivity, a smart-machine enhanced manufacturing process and a smart-machine enhanced distribution system. What will that entail? First, some attempt must be made to envision what this economy will look like and, second, how can it be managed to a humane end? Certainly, unless one defines civilization as a death cult where machines do all the work and we lay around taking drugs and watching bad television, it must be managed. We must direct the machine and not the other way around. Certainly, it must be to a humane end. We must enhance social existence, nothing less makes any sense whatsoever.
While there are a number of areas of intense research and development, three stand out as pointing the way to a humane society.
Artificial intelligence has the capacity to enhance human existence, both economic and social, by handling the mundane, tedious, details and protocols that harass us and devour our time.
Derivative of artificial intelligence are robots, even autonomous, thinking robots, those fearsome, delightful inventions.
Third, there are 3D printers, now even capable of placing metal in computer defined patterns, that can build intricate objects. Using these three elements I envision a humane factory as follows:
The human factor- a clever resourceful person of some mechanical insight.
The AI factor- a production manager, a business manager, a marketing manager, all under the direction of the human factor.
The robot factor- assembly robots, AI driven, able to learn new tasks reasonably quickly, capable and flexible.
The 3D printer- industrial 3D machines that can make intricate parts to exacting specifications for robot assembly.
The criteria for a Bespoke factory is- can it make an assembly robot with minimal outside components? Can it make a 3D printer with minimal outside components? That autonomous capability is beyond mass industrialism. It is the mark of the Age of Productivity.
The scheme for the Age of Productivity is simple:
There are factories. There are virtual markets matching production and sales. There are brokers directing AI assistants staffing those markets. There are AI enhanced points of sale. There are human consumers whose income is enhanced by a basic income, whose free education is AI enhanced.
If POM + POS generate z amount of dollars minus reasonable net profit then expenditures on education, basic income, and government equal z amount of dollars minus net profit. Of course, that's theoretical. Deviations would be normal.
This gives an x=5 equation for Value Dilution Economics. That is:
(POM+POS)/(education+basic income+ government+2)= .4 as value dilution factor
The value dilution is high because the Age of Productivity reduces human access to value addition, to the simple creation of wealth, in POM and POS. It necessarily is weighted to social utility as:
(money in circulation)(.4)= 'goodness` of currency
Do Well and Be Well
Next Blog:
The Necessity of Basic Income and Free Education in the Age of Productivity
What I am calling Value Dilution Economics is based upon the observation that when one leverages their economy, whether with Keynesian mechanics or supply side mechanics, one either overcooks their economy or overcooks their society and dilutes either the value of money or the quality of their social existence. It is a very reliable and historically evident relationship. We are now moving into the Age of Productivity, a smart-machine enhanced manufacturing process and a smart-machine enhanced distribution system. What will that entail? First, some attempt must be made to envision what this economy will look like and, second, how can it be managed to a humane end? Certainly, unless one defines civilization as a death cult where machines do all the work and we lay around taking drugs and watching bad television, it must be managed. We must direct the machine and not the other way around. Certainly, it must be to a humane end. We must enhance social existence, nothing less makes any sense whatsoever.
While there are a number of areas of intense research and development, three stand out as pointing the way to a humane society.
Artificial intelligence has the capacity to enhance human existence, both economic and social, by handling the mundane, tedious, details and protocols that harass us and devour our time.
Derivative of artificial intelligence are robots, even autonomous, thinking robots, those fearsome, delightful inventions.
Third, there are 3D printers, now even capable of placing metal in computer defined patterns, that can build intricate objects. Using these three elements I envision a humane factory as follows:
The human factor- a clever resourceful person of some mechanical insight.
The AI factor- a production manager, a business manager, a marketing manager, all under the direction of the human factor.
The robot factor- assembly robots, AI driven, able to learn new tasks reasonably quickly, capable and flexible.
The 3D printer- industrial 3D machines that can make intricate parts to exacting specifications for robot assembly.
The criteria for a Bespoke factory is- can it make an assembly robot with minimal outside components? Can it make a 3D printer with minimal outside components? That autonomous capability is beyond mass industrialism. It is the mark of the Age of Productivity.
The scheme for the Age of Productivity is simple:
There are factories. There are virtual markets matching production and sales. There are brokers directing AI assistants staffing those markets. There are AI enhanced points of sale. There are human consumers whose income is enhanced by a basic income, whose free education is AI enhanced.
If POM + POS generate z amount of dollars minus reasonable net profit then expenditures on education, basic income, and government equal z amount of dollars minus net profit. Of course, that's theoretical. Deviations would be normal.
This gives an x=5 equation for Value Dilution Economics. That is:
(POM+POS)/(education+basic income+ government+2)= .4 as value dilution factor
The value dilution is high because the Age of Productivity reduces human access to value addition, to the simple creation of wealth, in POM and POS. It necessarily is weighted to social utility as:
(money in circulation)(.4)= 'goodness` of currency
Do Well and Be Well
Next Blog:
The Necessity of Basic Income and Free Education in the Age of Productivity
Sunday, May 13, 2018
The Analytical Basis of a Humane Economy: A Speculation
Blog 2
It is necessary in proposing a new analytical model to show critical failure in the old model [Kuhn, 1967]. How hard is that with classic economics? 1872,1929, 2008. It's a piece of cake. It is not that those catastrophes occurred. It is that they were unexpected and in each case complex market interventions were required to keep the factories running,
The problem is not capitalism. If markets did not exist, we would invent them. Talent is a naive concept. It exists in the mind long before it is recognized in the person. That economic talent would be graced with unequal reward is intuitive. Likewise the essential arbitrage relationship, that greater risk requires greater reward, is very real and very human. Capitalism, in itself, is humane in the sense that it is all too human. We are too clever by half for our own good and we have win/lose outcomes wired into our cells. Capitalism is not the problem. It is the myopia of the economic analysis.
That analysis, in the process of utilizing available technology, has created our productivity driven mass industrialism with its aggregate demand and GDP. It is by these metrics definitely not human scale. It is by definition, in terms of any specific individual, not humane. Throw in the machines that make it go and the fact that its mechanisms manage to reduce humans to minions of the automated machine process and it is not incidentally inhumane. It is actually hostile. So, how do we characterize and analyze economic behavior so as to create a humane economy? Here is my speculative, somewhat naive, try:
Value Dilution Economics
There are two major aspects to economic behavior and, while each is perfectly comfortable with classic economics and accounting, the relationship of the two, production and distribution, is imperfectly expressed in the current model. To correct this, I propose two theoretical units, Point of Manufacture, POM, the point that the product leaves the factory, and Point of Sale, POS, the point that the product is in the possession of the end consumer. The number of socioeconomic sectors, education, basic income etc, between POM and POS I label x.
Arbitrarily I give each POM and POS a numeric value of 1. I then write the equation:
(POM + POS) / x = y
y is the dilution factor of the 'goodness' of the money used in all the transactions. Obviously, the value of y will fall between 1 and 0. Why do this? Because money, a value calculus allowing the comparative valuation of disparate products and services in a market, has only economic value. The social utility of economic activity varies inversely with its economic utility. Using money for its social utility dilutes its value much as putting too much in circulation does.
A humane economy has a target value of .5 because any greater number will be excessive economic utility and any lesser number will be excessive social utility. It is a matter of plugging this equation in across all transactions to calculate the goodness of a currency.
Material existence, the stuff of economics, lasts around 75 years at best. Social existence is the stuff of eternity. It only makes sense to balance social utility and economic utility and it makes absolutely no sense to do otherwise.
Do Well and Be Well.
Nest Blog:
Bespoke Production and the Humane Economy
It is necessary in proposing a new analytical model to show critical failure in the old model [Kuhn, 1967]. How hard is that with classic economics? 1872,1929, 2008. It's a piece of cake. It is not that those catastrophes occurred. It is that they were unexpected and in each case complex market interventions were required to keep the factories running,
The problem is not capitalism. If markets did not exist, we would invent them. Talent is a naive concept. It exists in the mind long before it is recognized in the person. That economic talent would be graced with unequal reward is intuitive. Likewise the essential arbitrage relationship, that greater risk requires greater reward, is very real and very human. Capitalism, in itself, is humane in the sense that it is all too human. We are too clever by half for our own good and we have win/lose outcomes wired into our cells. Capitalism is not the problem. It is the myopia of the economic analysis.
That analysis, in the process of utilizing available technology, has created our productivity driven mass industrialism with its aggregate demand and GDP. It is by these metrics definitely not human scale. It is by definition, in terms of any specific individual, not humane. Throw in the machines that make it go and the fact that its mechanisms manage to reduce humans to minions of the automated machine process and it is not incidentally inhumane. It is actually hostile. So, how do we characterize and analyze economic behavior so as to create a humane economy? Here is my speculative, somewhat naive, try:
Value Dilution Economics
There are two major aspects to economic behavior and, while each is perfectly comfortable with classic economics and accounting, the relationship of the two, production and distribution, is imperfectly expressed in the current model. To correct this, I propose two theoretical units, Point of Manufacture, POM, the point that the product leaves the factory, and Point of Sale, POS, the point that the product is in the possession of the end consumer. The number of socioeconomic sectors, education, basic income etc, between POM and POS I label x.
Arbitrarily I give each POM and POS a numeric value of 1. I then write the equation:
(POM + POS) / x = y
y is the dilution factor of the 'goodness' of the money used in all the transactions. Obviously, the value of y will fall between 1 and 0. Why do this? Because money, a value calculus allowing the comparative valuation of disparate products and services in a market, has only economic value. The social utility of economic activity varies inversely with its economic utility. Using money for its social utility dilutes its value much as putting too much in circulation does.
A humane economy has a target value of .5 because any greater number will be excessive economic utility and any lesser number will be excessive social utility. It is a matter of plugging this equation in across all transactions to calculate the goodness of a currency.
Material existence, the stuff of economics, lasts around 75 years at best. Social existence is the stuff of eternity. It only makes sense to balance social utility and economic utility and it makes absolutely no sense to do otherwise.
Do Well and Be Well.
Nest Blog:
Bespoke Production and the Humane Economy
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
